Who will have the last laugh on the MTN, AGF tax dispute?

Who will have the last laugh on the MTN, AGF tax dispute?, Conquest Online Magazine
The last has not been heard from the tumultuous trajectory that the Nigerian subsidiary of telecoms behemoth MTN has navigated for the past four years as it had to contend and manage the pronouncement by Nigerian Communications Commission (NCC) to penalize their inability to disconnect 5.2 million unregistered subscribers on its network. The annals of government and regulatory brickbats has not abated as a Federal High Court domiciled in Ikoyi has set the hearing of a court case between MTN Nigeria and the Attorney General of the Federation for January 30, 2020 following the demand that the telco firm should pay 2 billion US dollars in tax arrears.
This development constitutes an ugly headache for the multi-national business entity based in Johannesburg, South Africa with OU’s in many African, European and Asian countries as Nigeria represents its largest market in terms of subscriber base for the eight largest mobile network operator in the world. The latest sledgehammer in the shape of tax arrears cover import duties, VAT and withholding taxes on foreign imports and payments. This new installment of taxation led the head honcho of MTN Group, Rob Shuter, to hurl the accusation that Nigeria’s AGF, Abubakar Malami, of exercising “powers beyond his limit” by demanding $2 billion in tax arrears, something Shuter says he is not mandated to do.
In reaction to this unsavory turn of events that could leave a massive dent on the balance sheet of MTN Nigeria, the company filed a suit seeking damages and challenging the powers of the AGF to deal with tax matters. It creates a scenario with questions begging for answers and MTN insists that even if the court rules in favor that the AGF does have powers over tax matters, it does not imply the assessment of a $2 billion tax debt is “legitimate.”
MTN’s reaction to the AGF’s statement, it described it as “regrettable and disconcerting” that the case has been reopened despite multiple tax assessments carried out over the years. “MTN has conducted“MTN has conducted a detailed review of these claims and provided evidence of tax remittance to the Attorney General’s office,” it said.
“The Attorney General’s notice indicates that he is rejecting this evidence. We believe that all taxes due to the Nigerian government have been paid and these allegations have not been raised by any of the revenue-generating agencies that MTN engages with regularly, and from whom MTN has received numerous awards for compliance.” In this light, MTN Nigeria is seeking N3 billion in damages and legal costs from the Federal Government of Nigeria On five grounds linked directly to the office of the attorney general of the federation (AGF).
It is imperative for the relevant stakeholders herein to quickly resolve this knotty issue that affects investors relations and confidence in the short to long term. It seems that the middle ground herein will be to employ alternative dispute resolution (ADR) channels to reach an amicable resolution for the business concern listed in the prestigious club of companies in the Nigeria Stock Exchange (NSE) Premium Board (a listing segment for the elite group of issuers that meet the Exhange’s most stringent corporate governance and listing standards) after it’s listing on the bourse in May 2019.

In conclusion, MTN’s board of directors that was recently rejigged reflects individuals such as former Executive Vice Chairman, Nigerian Communications Commission (NCC), Ernest Ndukwe as chairman designate. Other appointees include the telcos Chief Executive Officer, Ferdinand Moolman; Michael Onochie Ajukwu -independent non-executive director; former PENCOM helmsman, Muhammad K. Ahmad -independent non-executive director; Andrew Alli -non-executive director; Rhidwaan Gasant -independent non-executive director; former Communications Technology, Omobola Johnson -non-executive director; and A.B. Mahmoud -non-executive director. It also includes Ralph Mupita; Paul Norman; former Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS) Chairman, Ifueko Okauru, non-executive director; Jens Schulte-Bockum; Group CEO, Rob Shuter, and Karl Toriola, who have the requisite credentials to navigate the murky waters of government and regulatory affairs ecosystem of arguably the largest sub Saharan market.

176 Views