Authorities in Hollywood, Florida have arrested a young couple accused of killing their three-week-old son and attempting to stage his death to appear accidental.
Crystal Garcia, 21, and Anfernee Watts, 25, were taken into custody on April 8, 2026, and charged with aggravated manslaughter of a child in connection with the infant’s death in August 2025.
According to an arrest affidavit obtained by People Magazine, the couple allegedly provided inconsistent and misleading accounts to investigators in an effort to conceal what truly happened.
Emergency responders were called to the home on August 1 after Garcia reported finding the baby unresponsive in his playpen. At the time, Watts claimed he had left earlier that morning for a job interview an assertion authorities later determined to be false.
Garcia initially told investigators she had fed and cared for the baby before putting him down and taking a nap. She claimed she later discovered something was wrong when she returned to check on him.
However, investigators noted that she did not immediately seek help, stating she did not want to alarm her mother, who was also in the home.
Months later, in March, the infant’s cause of death was officially ruled as suffocation.
Investigators allege that Garcia restrained the baby by tightly wrapping him in a blanket, strapping him into a car seat, and placing him in a bathtub. Authorities further claim that loud music was played in an apparent attempt to mask the child’s cries.
According to police, Garcia failed to seek medical assistance after realizing the baby was unresponsive and instead participated in staging the scene.
Authorities reported signs that the home had been cleaned extensively, with bleach and wipes used throughout. Items within the room appeared altered or removed.
Watts allegedly admitted to discarding baby-related items, including bottles, while surveillance footage showed Garcia disposing of trash and handling cleaning supplies shortly before calling emergency services.
Investigators also observed a disposable changing pad with what appeared to be blood spots, and noted a strong smell of bleach in the home. Watts reportedly attributed this to an accidental spill.
Further complicating the case, Watts’ mother told police that Garcia admitted days after the incident that she had lied about what happened.
Authorities also revealed that Garcia later contacted police multiple times attempting to “clarify” her statements. In voice messages, she allegedly admitted to smothering the baby.
Both Garcia and Watts now face multiple charges, including:
- Aggravated manslaughter of a child
- Child neglect causing great bodily harm
- Tampering with physical evidence
- Failure to report a death
- Providing false information to law enforcement
The couple is currently being held at the Broward County Jail as they await trial.













