In a significant ruling reported by Conquest Magazine, the Court of Appeal in Abuja has dismissed an appeal filed by Julius Abure challenging the leadership structure of the Labour Party, thereby affirming Nenadi Usman as the legitimate head of the party’s caretaker committee.
The unanimous judgment was delivered by a three-member panel of the appellate court comprising Justices Oyejoju Oyewumi, Abba Mohammed, and Eberechi Nyesom-Wike. The court upheld the earlier decision of the Federal High Court, which had recognised a 29-member caretaker committee led by Usman.
Delivering the lead judgment, Justice Oyewumi held that the leadership dispute had already been resolved by the Supreme Court, which nullified the convention that produced Abure as national chairman and effectively terminated his tenure. The court further noted that the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) had been directed to recognise Usman’s leadership in line with that ruling.
The appellate court also ruled that the lower court acted within its constitutional powers in ordering Independent National Electoral Commission to recognise the caretaker committee, stating that the decision was necessary to prevent a leadership vacuum within the party.
Abure’s claims of denial of fair hearing were dismissed, with the court describing the appeal as lacking merit and constituting an abuse of court process. The panel further faulted his actions as “forum shopping,” citing his attempt to seek relief at the Nasarawa State High Court on an issue already determined by the Supreme Court.
“On the whole, I agree with the decision and conclusion of the trial court as the same, being in accordance with the Constitution,” Justice Oyewumi stated, adding that the lower court reached a sound and defensible conclusion.
The appeal, filed as CA/ABJ/CV/255/2026, was consequently dismissed. The court also imposed a ₦10 million cost against Abure for what it described as a waste of judicial time on a matter already conclusively settled.
The ruling reinforces the legal standing of the caretaker committee and brings further judicial clarity to the ongoing leadership tussle within the Labour Party.














