A 74-year-old blind man facing a first-degree murder charge in Florida has made an unusual proposal in court, offering to plead guilty and accept a life sentence in exchange for a Philly cheesesteak, fries and a Pepsi.
Robert Kessler, who is also charged with abuse of a dead body, told the judge he was considering an open plea that would allow him to admit guilt without a negotiated sentencing agreement.
Explaining his proposal, Kessler said he would accept life imprisonment if he received the meal he wanted.
When the judge asked him to clarify his request, Kessler specified that the cheesesteak should come with onions and mayonnaise, alongside an order of fries and a 20-ounce Pepsi.
He then explained why he was making the offer, saying, “Save the jury. Save the taxpayers.”
The judge, who said he had been handling cases for nearly 40 years, admitted he had never encountered such a request before.
He explained that providing food as part of a plea agreement would be inappropriate, describing the proposal as “wrong in a thousand ways”. However, he assured Kessler that he would still have lunch that day.
Kessler subsequently withdrew his offer, telling the court he did not want to enter an open plea and would prefer to proceed with jury selection.
He is accused of killing 47-year-old Stephanie Crone Overholt and dismembering her body. Kessler had initially represented himself in the case but later changed his mind.
His unusual proposal did not result in a plea agreement, leaving the case to proceed towards trial.














