Pastor Pleads Guilty to Diverting $504,000 From Historic Church

A former pastor of Vernon African Methodist Episcopal (AME) Church in Tulsa, Oklahoma, Keith Rydell Mayes Sr., has pleaded guilty to diverting more than $504,000 from the historic church.

Mayes, 63, pleaded guilty to bank fraud and tax evasion on September 14, 2026, after federal prosecutors said he misappropriated $504,313.88 between March 2022 and November 2025.

Mayes became the church’s senior pastor in October 2021.

Prosecutors said he later opened a bank account labelled “Administrative Expenses”, which he controlled as the sole authorised signatory.

According to the prosecution, Mayes used the account to collect donations without the knowledge or approval of the church’s governing leadership.

One of the major transactions involved a donor who gave the church stocks worth $365,000 in 2021 and 2022. Investigators said Mayes liquidated the shares, deposited the proceeds into a church account and diverted most of the money for personal use.

Prosecutors said the money was spent on gambling, personal expenses and firearms. Mayes also failed to report the funds as income, resulting in more than $205,000 in unpaid federal taxes.

Under a plea agreement, Mayes agreed to repay $504,313.88, including $205,765.60 owed to the Internal Revenue Service. He also agreed to forfeit firearms and ammunition purchased with the money.

The church’s 12th Episcopal District has distanced itself from the financial dealings described in the federal case.

Bishop Silvester Scott Beaman said the actions outlined by federal prosecutors were not authorised by the congregation or the leadership of Vernon AME Church.

The district confirmed that Mayes stopped serving as pastor in May 2026 and said the church had reviewed its financial procedures following the case.

Vernon AME Church is of particular historical significance in Tulsa. Its basement survived the 1921 Tulsa Race Massacre, in which much of the city’s Greenwood district, a thriving Black community, was destroyed. The congregation later rebuilt the church above the surviving basement.

The Episcopal District urged the public not to allow the case to overshadow the church’s long history.

“We ask that the actions of one individual not be allowed to define a church that has served Tulsa for more than 120 years,” the district said.

Mayes was released on bond and remains under supervision pending sentencing.

 

68 Views