Lineker Suggests Possible Beef Behind Scholes’ Criticism of Carrick

Former England international Gary Lineker has raised questions over the repeated criticism directed at Michael Carrick by his former Manchester United teammate Paul Scholes.

Carrick has been in charge of United on an interim basis since the departure of Ruben Amorim last November, and his early performances in the role have drawn praise from sections of the club’s supporters. His strong start has also sparked debate about whether he should be considered for the permanent managerial position.

Despite this, some former United players, including Gary Neville, Roy Keane and Scholes, have maintained that the club should conduct a wider search rather than appoint Carrick full-time.

The criticism has occasionally attracted controversy. Keane previously drew backlash after referencing Carrick’s wife while discussing the former midfielder’s suitability for the role, while Scholes recently faced criticism for a sarcastic social media post following Carrick’s first defeat as interim manager against Newcastle United. The post was later deleted after it sparked a negative reaction from fans.

Former United defender Patrice Evra also weighed in on the situation, accusing Scholes, Keane and Neville of being overly harsh in their assessment of Carrick, suggesting their comments were partly aimed at creating media attention.

Speaking on The Rest Is Football podcast, Lineker suggested there might be deeper reasons behind Scholes’ stance.

“It does seem like there’s a little bit of beef between Paul Scholes and Michael Carrick,” Lineker said. “He’s digging him out and not really showing much support for someone he played with for years.”

Lineker added that the situation appeared unusual given their history as teammates.

Scholes and Carrick shared the midfield for Manchester United between 2006 and 2013, making around 160 appearances together. During that period, they helped the club secure several honours, including five Premier League titles and one UEFA Champions League trophy

123 Views